THEY OWNED THE STAGE!!
- Dan
- Pethead Fanatic
- Posts: 2529
- Joined: Thu Oct 09, 2003 4:17 am
- #1 Album: This Means War!
- Pethead since: 1987
- Location: USA
- x 80
Re: THEY OWNED THE STAGE!!
Yeah, I get that. If you listen to pop music from the 70s and 80s, you'll find that Volz actually has a quintessential pop voice. It was the style back then for pop singers to have a smoother, more dextrous, more nuanced voice. Listen to Journey, Chicago, Queen, Boston, Bon Jovi, Rush, Styx, Paul McCartney, Kansas, REO Speedwagon, Toto, Europe, and I could name probably a dozen more. There were, of course, some "go ahead" rock singers like Sammy Hagar, Jimmy Page, and Steven Tyler, but Volz's vocal stylings were out of place. To say that Volz didn't have a rock voice might be true, but he was "too polished" is an observation of the prevailing styles of time.
0 x
-
- Pethead
- Posts: 271
- Joined: Sun Jul 09, 2006 6:08 pm
- Pethead since: 1990
- Location: Puerto Rico
- x 2
- Contact:
Re: THEY OWNED THE STAGE!!
This is pretty much my take on it. I think Volz was the right fit at the time, and I like his voice in those albums a lot. But when he left, I think Petra was lucky enough to find someone like Schlitt, who was the right fit for the style of rock that was shaping up in the 80's. They were both in the right place at the right time.Mountain Man wrote:Yeah, I don't get that. If you listen to rock music from the 70s and 80s, you'll find that Volz actually has a quintessential classic rock voice. It was the style back then for lead singers to have a smoother, more dextrous, more nuanced voice. Listen to Journey, Chicago, Queen, Boston, Bon Jovi, Rush, Styx, Paul McCartney, Kansas, REO Speedwagon, Toto, Europe, and I could name probably a dozen more. There were, of course, some "go ahead" rock singers like Sammy Hagar, Jimmy Page, and Steven Tyler, but Volz's vocal stylings weren't at all out of place. To say that Volz didn't have a rock voice, or that he was "too polished" is to ignore one of the prevailing styles of time.
0 x
- Mountain Man
- Pethead Fanatic
- Posts: 1387
- Joined: Fri Oct 10, 2003 9:11 pm
- #1 Album: Wake-Up Call
- Pethead since: 1983
- x 266
Re: THEY OWNED THE STAGE!!
Except those aren't "pop" bands.Dan wrote:It was the style back then for pop singers to have a smoother, more dextrous, more nuanced voice. Listen to Journey, Chicago, Queen, Boston, Bon Jovi, Rush, Styx, Paul McCartney, Kansas, REO Speedwagon, Toto, Europe, and I could name probably a dozen more.
0 x
- fiendik
- Pethead
- Posts: 132
- Joined: Sat May 10, 2014 11:48 am
- #1 Album: Beat The System
- Pethead since: 2010
- x 1
Re: THEY OWNED THE STAGE!!
I assume It's just too obvious; or because no-one cares Lawry is easily ahead of Slick, at least at first. Lawry gradually lost his importance in the music as they headed towards a harder sound. I personally am not that crazy about most of Slick's recorded works, with a few exceptions. Dunno if it was just the music or what, but NOTW keyboarding doesn't really resonate with me much.Mountain Man wrote:Well duh.superfly wrote:CITAS
So here's an off the wall question: Petra fans get up in arms debating the merits of Greg Volz versus John Schlitt, but why don't we ever have heated discussions comparing John Slick to John Lawry, or Mark Kelly to Ronny Cates?
As for the Volz debate (our favorite! ) I think it's interesting exactly how the #1 Album corresponds to ones opinion about what singers sounded like in the 80s. I would say he was what people expected in a rock singer back then; no-one was surprised by the fact he was in a rock band. These days, of course, no rock group would choose to sound like that, but that doesn't change the way it was in the 80s. I listen to almost exclusively 70s & 80s music, and can say for a fact that smooth voices were a rock thing. They were in pop, too, but Petra didn't sing pop, and neither did the host of secular rock bands that sounded essentially the same. You can't say that Volz was out of keeping with the times (he was in the #1 Christian Rock group, after all). You can say that he's out of keeping with your musical tastes, and apparently that is the current objective.
0 x
"Fiends are a gift from above, fiends are devoted and true..."
-
- Extreme Pethead Fanatic
- Posts: 3947
- Joined: Thu Oct 02, 2003 10:56 am
- #1 Album: JAH
- Pethead since: 1980
- Location: Earth
- x 56
Re: THEY OWNED THE STAGE!!
Mountain Man wrote:Yeah, I don't get that. If you listen to rock music from the 70s and 80s, you'll find that Volz actually has a quintessential classic rock voice. It was the style back then for lead singers to have a smoother, more dextrous, more nuanced voice. Listen to Journey, Chicago, Queen, Boston, Bon Jovi, Rush, Styx, Paul McCartney, Kansas, REO Speedwagon, Toto, Europe, and I could name probably a dozen more. There were, of course, some "go ahead" rock singers like Sammy Hagar, Jimmy Page, and Steven Tyler, but Volz's vocal stylings weren't at all out of place. To say that Volz didn't have a rock voice, or that he was "too polished" is to ignore one of the prevailing styles of time.
The weird thing about the bands you listed is that most of their lead singers are closer to the Schlitt style over the Volz style. I would say that Volz would have fit in nicely with the likes of Chicago, Queen, REO, & Toto but I feel the rest would be more suited for Schlitt. Like I said before it's just my opinion and no one is right/wrong in the matter just we feel different about the styles and where they fit into the mix of things.
0 x
FORGIVE! FORGET! & LET GO!
-
- Extreme Pethead Fanatic
- Posts: 3947
- Joined: Thu Oct 02, 2003 10:56 am
- #1 Album: JAH
- Pethead since: 1980
- Location: Earth
- x 56
Re: THEY OWNED THE STAGE!!
Chicago(which they themselves will say they are totally pop) and most of Queens stuff is pop.Mountain Man wrote:Except those aren't "pop" bands.Dan wrote:It was the style back then for pop singers to have a smoother, more dextrous, more nuanced voice. Listen to Journey, Chicago, Queen, Boston, Bon Jovi, Rush, Styx, Paul McCartney, Kansas, REO Speedwagon, Toto, Europe, and I could name probably a dozen more.
0 x
FORGIVE! FORGET! & LET GO!
- Mountain Man
- Pethead Fanatic
- Posts: 1387
- Joined: Fri Oct 10, 2003 9:11 pm
- #1 Album: Wake-Up Call
- Pethead since: 1983
- x 266
-
- Extreme Pethead Fanatic
- Posts: 3947
- Joined: Thu Oct 02, 2003 10:56 am
- #1 Album: JAH
- Pethead since: 1980
- Location: Earth
- x 56
Re: THEY OWNED THE STAGE!!
You asked a simple question and got some complex answers. All it is, is differing opinions on the subject and I feel that neither side of the debate should be discredited; I'm in the minority and I am perfectly fine with it. BTW I've always felt that the albums from 81-83 have always sounded like what was really popular in the secular and mainstream in the late 70's. Petra was 2-5 years behind the secular market, but seem to hit the CCM market just at the right time.Mountain Man wrote:What have I done?
0 x
FORGIVE! FORGET! & LET GO!
- Dan
- Pethead Fanatic
- Posts: 2529
- Joined: Thu Oct 09, 2003 4:17 am
- #1 Album: This Means War!
- Pethead since: 1987
- Location: USA
- x 80
Re: THEY OWNED THE STAGE!!
Found this magazine cover, should settle the Pop issue.
- Attachments
-
- grexpop.jpg (89.78 KiB) Viewed 5438 times
0 x
- Mountain Man
- Pethead Fanatic
- Posts: 1387
- Joined: Fri Oct 10, 2003 9:11 pm
- #1 Album: Wake-Up Call
- Pethead since: 1983
- x 266
Re: THEY OWNED THE STAGE!!
It was more of a joke than a serious question. I didn't expect it to erupt into an actual debate.executioner wrote:You asked a simple question and got some complex answers. All it is, is differing opinions on the subject and I feel that neither side of the debate should be discredited; I'm in the minority and I am perfectly fine with it. BTW I've always felt that the albums from 81-83 have always sounded like what was really popular in the secular and mainstream in the late 70's. Petra was 2-5 years behind the secular market, but seem to hit the CCM market just at the right time.Mountain Man wrote:What have I done?
0 x
Re: THEY OWNED THE STAGE!!
Sorry, JS is a very different keyboardist than JL. In my book, Slick is the better musician. Slick is WAY more skilled and has a LOT more soul than you were allowed to hear on Petra records. JDB has even said this much. JS is a guy with super high intelligence. JL is a very smart guy too, but JS was involved creating some of the gear guys like JL played and has gone on to do some high tech work above any Petra band member's pay grade.
0 x
-
- Founding or Official Member of Petra
- Posts: 103
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 1:44 am
- #1 Album: More Power To Ya
- Pethead since: 1979
- x 44
Re: THEY OWNED THE STAGE!!
Slick here. I have a lot to say, all positive. Started to post it, but decided to save it to a text file and wait to see if anyone is interested.
0 x
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 15 guests